Archives → Book Reviews
By the late spring of 1945, Germany had lost a war, its honor and millions of dead. There was more to come. The Allies had decided that the country’s east should be carved up between Poland and the Soviet Union and that its German inhabitants should be moved to the truncated Reich. There they would encounter Sudeten Germans, Czechoslovakia’s second largest ethnic group, now also scheduled for deportation. In August 1945, the United Kingdom, the United States and the Soviet Union agreed at Potsdam that these transfers, which had in any case already begun, should be “orderly and humane.” They [...]
The Tragedy Europe Forgot
August 9, 2012
Orderly and Humane By R.M. Douglas.; published originally in the Wall Street Journal
Dystopias — dark, funhouse mirrors of our fears — will always be with us. Nineteen Eighty-Four was the product of a time when Big Brother Stalin was on the march, and the Eloi and the Morlocks of The Time Machine reflected H. G. Wells’s anxiety about where the onrush of 19th-century capitalism could lead. So what to make of the success of a “young adult” trilogy set in a North America that has — here a shout-out to a fashionably green vision of global catastrophe — emerged after “the droughts, the storms, the fires, the encroaching seas that swallowed up [...]
Quidditch, It’s Not
July 30, 2012
The Hunger Games, Catching Fire, and Mockingjay by Suzanne Collins.; published originally in National Review
The starving, shattered Europe that Hitler left behind is a topic so vast, so terrible and so chaotic that it is hard to see how it could be confined to a single volume. The British historian Keith Lowe has not attempted to do so. In Savage Continent he uses just some of the fragments of history to assemble a vivid, if occasionally unevenly written, portrait of a broken, vagrant place oscillating between ancient barbarism and a post-apocalyptic future. With the Marshall Plan as yet undreamed, and Marshal Stalin on the prowl, no safe haven lay in sight. Such a vision [...]
Darkness at dawn
June 1, 2012
Savage Continent: Europe in the Aftermath of World War II by Keith Lowe.; published originally in The New Criterion
How to make a nation? In Vanished Kingdoms, his fascinating — and characteristically hefty — new book chronicling the rise and fall of 15 European states (from Visigoth Tolosa to the good-riddance empire of the Soviets), historian Norman Davies offers a number of suggestions. They include “good fortune, benevolent neighbors, and a sense of purpose.” There are nods to the power of a common language and a shared myth, and an implied recognition of the usefulness of conquest (where now are the Baltic people, the Prusai, whose land formed the core of ascendant Teutonic Prussia?), but little focus on the [...]
What Lies Beneath
April 30, 2012
Vanished Kingdoms: The Rise and Fall of States and Nations, by Norman Davies.; published originally in National Review
Anglophobes or egalitarians still looking for confirmation that the English aristocracy is no longer what it was may find Marcus Scriven’s Splendour & Squalor the most satisfying read since whatever it was that Sarah Ferguson last wrote. These are well-told tales of well-born ruin to savor, complete with grubby interludes, penny ante crises, and tawdry finales that all combine to make a wider, and even more conclusive, point about the decline of the old social order: The aristocratic fiascos of the 20th century are those of a shrunken and shriveled caste. They simply cannot compete with the epic follies of [...]
Downhill from Here
January 2, 2012
Splendour & Squalor: The Disgrace and Disintegration of Three Aristocratic Dynasties by Marcus Scriven; published originally in The Weekly Standard
It may be that, despite wars, revolutions, genocides, and jihad, there are still a few trusting souls who believe that modernity, technological progress, and reason move forward together in bright, benign convoy. If so, they cannot have read Heaven on Earth, an ideal tough love gift for any Candides of your acquaintance. In it, Richard Landes describes the past, present, and probable future of millennialism, the umbrella term for a collection of beliefs in a world overturned and remade that has resonated, seductive and destructive, through the ages. It is a bracing and instructive read, if not always an easy [...]
Omega Men
January 1, 2012
Heaven on Earth: The Varieties of the Millennial Experience by Richard Landes.; published originally in The New Criterion
Looking for someone to turn lemons into lemonade? In his own distinctive way, Alexander Theroux might be your man. In 2008, Mr. Theroux, an American author (among his works are “Laura Warholic,” a novel, and “The Strange Case of Edward Gorey”), moved to Estonia, the northernmost Baltic state, to join his artist-wife, who was then in the former Soviet republic on a “dismally small” Fulbright grant. It didn’t work out. It was never going to. But it appears that Mr. Theroux did not so much succumb to despair as embrace it. In “Estonia: A Ramble Through the Periphery,” he mines [...]
Stranger In a Strange Land
December 15, 2011
Estonia By Alexander Theroux; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
In 1945, Stalin seized East Prussia, Germany’s venerable redoubt on the Baltic Sea, as a spoil of war. A portion went to the “People’s Republic” that the Soviets had just created in Poland. He kept the rest. The last surviving Germans were killed or deported. The cozy old Königsberg of the Teutonic Knights—the home, during the Enlightenment, of no less than Immanuel Kant—was transformed into Kaliningrad—a bleak Soviet place named after Mikhail Kalinin, the token peasant who was titular head of Stalin’s USSR. Nearly 70 years later, the countries behind these borders have changed, but the frontiers have not, and [...]
Eastern Reproaches
November 11, 2011
Forgotten Land: Journeys Among The Ghosts of East Prussia By Max Egremont; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
Like the ideal victim in the rougher sort of slasher flick, the Motion Picture Production Code was clean-cut, gradually gutted and took a while to die. But there’s no need to mourn. Its slow passing (the code was finally scrapped in 1968) threw open a door through which tumbled the horror that turned the 1970s into a golden decade for the darkest of cinema. Born again in “Rosemary’s Baby” (1968), the Devil became a superstar in “The Exorcist” (1972). Meanwhile, monsters terrified the multiplex in movies such as “Night of the Living Dead” (1968), “The Hills Have Eyes” (1977) and [...]
When the Silver Screen Went Red
July 23, 2011
Shock Value by Jason Zinoman.; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
Twentieth-century totalitarian art did not just gild the cage; it helped to build it. Paintings, movies, sculpture, architecture and festivals of choreographed joy were vital elements in the Nazi and Communist attempts to remake man. It is key to our understanding of the nightmare states that resulted, argues Igor Golomstock, and deserves to be classified as a distinctive artistic genre alongside Modernism, of which it was both byway and heir. Like Modernism, totalitarian art was intended to help sweep away what had gone before, but unlike Modernism it was prepared to steal from the past to do so. The style [...]
Masters of the Dark Arts
June 25, 2011
Totalitarian Art By Igor Golomstock.; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
The fall of Singapore is not news, the Rattenkrieg in Stalingrad’s ruins is not news, the grotesque theater of arrival at the Auschwitz railway siding is not news, but Andrew Roberts’s narrative gifts are such that it is almost impossible to read his retelling of these nightmares without some feeling of encountering the new. Almost: World War II is too familiar a saga for that. Still, Mr. Roberts, a distinguished British military historian, has produced a volume that serves as a comprehensive and clear (good maps too) introduction to this most sprawling of conflicts while adding fresh insights for those already well-versed in [...]
The Province of Chance
June 20, 2011
The Storm of War: A New History of the Second World War, by Andrew Roberts.; published originally in National Review
The most remarkable thing about “The Way Back,” the 2010 film by Peter Weir, was neither its protagonists (escapees from the Soviet gulag system who trekked thousands of miles to their freedom) nor the curious tale of the almost certainly fictional 1956 “memoir” that inspired it (Slawomir Rawicz’s “The Long Walk”). No, what distinguished “The Way Back” was its depiction of life in Stalin’s camps. There have been a handful of films on this topic, but, as observed Anne Applebaum, author of a fine 2004 history of the gulag, this was the first time it had been given the full [...]
A World Behind Barbed Wire
April 23, 2011
A series of books on the Soviet Gulag.; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
Winter is bleak enough as it is. This year the gloom was deepened by the publication of How to Change the World: Tales of Marx and Marxism, by Eric Hobsbawm, one of Britain’s most feted historians, and, oh yes, a man who stuck with the Communist party until 1991 despite a global killing spree that took perhaps one hundred million lives. Naturally Hobsbawm’s new book has triggered the usual hosannas from the usual congregation for, to quote the Guardian, this “grand old man.” There had, of course, been that minor unpleasantness back in the 1990s when Hobsbawm had appeared to [...]
Naming the Crime
March 18, 2011
Bloodlands by Timothy Snyder; Stalin's Genocides by Norman Naimark; published originally in National Review Online
Stalin’s observation that the death of one man is a tragedy but the death of a million is a statistic helps explain why some of the finest portraits of 20th-century totalitarianism have been miniatures. Ivan Denisovich’s “day without a dark cloud” and the hunt for the Jewish schoolboys in Louis Malle’s Au revoir les enfants illuminate horrors that stretch far beyond one outpost of the Gulag or a stagnant Vichy town. The decision by the Canadian historian Gary Bruce to focus his new history of the East German secret police, the Stasi (Staatssicherheit), on Perleberg and Gransee, two out-of-the-way districts [...]
Big Bruder Watching
January 24, 2011
The Inside Story of the Stasi, by Gary Bruce.; published originally in The Weekly Standard
It says something about present anxieties that a 35-year-old account of Weimar hyperinflation has come into vogue. In early 2010, Adam Fergusson’s long-out-of-print volume was trading online for four-figure sums. There were (false) reports of kind words about it from Warren Buffett. Now back in print, this once obscure book from 1975 has been selling briskly. Just another manifestation of the financial millenarianism now sweeping the land? Perhaps, but “When Money Dies” remains a fascinating and disturbing book. The death of the German mark (it took 20 of them to buy a British pound in 1914 but 310 billion in [...]
A Flock of Black Swans
December 30, 2010
When Money Dies: The Nightmare of Deficit Spending, Devaluation and Hyperinflation in Weimar Germany, by Adam Fergusson.; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
You can pick and choose from any number of disasters, but it is clear that long years immersed in the heavy-metal simplicities of the later Cold War left U.S. intelligence agencies ill-prepared for the complexities of the global struggle with Islamism—a contest in which ideology, ethnicity and national interest collide and an overwhelming technological advantage is not, by itself, enough to deliver victory. The porous borders and shifting contours of this slippery new world require something subtler, something new. Yet they would have seemed strangely familiar to Otto Katz (1895-1952), a Soviet agent of the interwar era and now the [...]
Tinker, Tailor, Pilot, Spy
November 26, 2010
The Dangerous Otto Katz: The Many Lives of a Soviet Spy by Jonathan Miles; Bridge of Spies: A True Story of the Cold War by Giles Whittell; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
I got Dan Brown, I really did. The history was bunk, the prose was Lego, and yet there was something there — that maddening, tantalizing what’s-going-to-happen-next — that kept me turning, turning, turning the pages deep into the night. By contrast, the success of Stieg Larsson, the Swedish thriller writer, who would — had he not died tragically young (only 50) in 2004, leaving just three (completed) novels behind — now be seen as a challenger to the impious Mr. Brown, leaves me more than a little amazed. Collectively known as the Millennium trilogy, those three books have together sold over [...]
Young Lisbeth
November 10, 2010
The Millennium Trilogy by Stieg Larsson.; published originally in National Review
Right at the beginning of “Life,” there’s a hint of the glorious Spinal Tapestry that Keith Richards’s autobiography might have been. Using words that are rather less decorous than a family newspaper can permit, Mr. Richards recalls how: “[1975] was the tour of the giant inflatable [phallus]. It came rising up from the stage as Mick sang ‘Starf—er.’ It was great was the [phallus], though we paid for it later in Mick’s wanting props at every tour after that, to cover his insecurities. There was a huge business of getting elephants on stage in Memphis until they ended up crashing [...]
So You Want To Be a Rock ‘n’ Roll Star
October 29, 2010
"Life" by Keith Richards; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
Toffs remain big box office in Britain as, less classily, does Adolf Hitler. Combine both in one glamorous, self-mythologizing family, and it’s easy to see why the six Mitford sisters have helped feed generations of English journalists and historians. The daughters of a wildly eccentric peer, they made a splash in Britain’s interwar high society. Two of them then immersed themselves in the more questionable pleasures of fascism—Unity ornamented the Führer’s inner circle, and Diana married Oswald Mosley, Britain’s would-be Duce. Meanwhile, Jessica (1917-96), the fifth sister, known as Decca, took a different course, to civil-war Spain (againstFranco). What followed—as [...]
Irrepressible
October 2, 2010
Irrepressible: The Life and Times of Jessica Mitford By Leslie Brody.; published originally in The Wall Street Journal
We’ll never know for sure what the English writer William Golding (1911–93), a publicly private man, would have thought about the publication of this book. Thanks partly to Golding’s failure to cooperate, no biographies of him were published during his lifetime, but the assumption that follows from that would probably be wrong. Feast has followed famine: To help him in his work on this book, the Golding family granted John Carey, a prominent Oxford academic, distinguished literary critic, and acquaintance of Golding, access to the author’s previously closed archive. It was a hoard too extensive not to have been designed [...]
Through A Glass, Darkly
August 16, 2010
William Golding, The Man Who Wrote Lord of the Flies: A Life, by John Carey; published originally in National Review
Imagine that a critic had written a book centered on Olympia and Triumph of the Will without emphasizing the fact, however well known, that the Nazi ideology to which the director of those movies had dedicated her talent had led to the slaughter of millions. You can’t. It would be inconceivable. Few can deny that, at their best (if that’s the adjective), Leni Riefenstahl’s films were works of genius, but their hideous context should never be ignored. And generally it isn’t. The artists who promoted Soviet communism are given an easier ride. To take perhaps the most prominent, Sergei Eisenstein is remembered today as [...]
Tower of Power
June 14, 2010
Tatlin’s Tower: Monument to Revolution, by Norbert Lynton (Yale, 240 pp., $50).; published originally in The Weekly Standard
To be asked to pick the best book that you have read in the past year is usually an invitation to equivocation, but that was not the case on one evening in the late 1990s when my interrogator—and that’s the word—was the Baroness Thatcher of Kesteven. “Well,” I replied, “The Commissar Vanishes.” She hadn’t heard of it. Good. Liked the book’s concept. Better. Told an aide to write down the title. Better still. Didn’t know that it was written by an unreconstructed lefty. Ah, just as well. David King’s The Commissar Vanishes: The Falsification of Photographs and Art in Stalin’s Russia (1997) [...]
King & the Commissars
March 1, 2010
Red Star Over Russia: A Visual History of the Soviet Union by David King.; published originally in The New Criterion
One of the most remarkable aspects of Winston Churchill’s sprawling epic of a life was the way that he was able to cram it all in — to do all that — in a mere 90 years. It is only marginally less miraculous that Paul Johnson has now managed to make an excellent job of summing up that life — and, no less important, offer up a good measure of the man who lived it — in a book of a little under 200 pages. This is not a “definitive” Churchill. For that, turn to the massive official biography begun [...]
Walking With Destiny
December 10, 2009
Churchill by Paul Johnson; published originally in National Review
Infuriated by the high-church, high-Tory critiques of a British historian impertinent enough to suggest that the tercentenary of England’s Glorious Revolution of 1688 was not worth celebrating, Mrs. Thatcher’s then Lord Chancellor jibed that “academic historians never make their money by saying that the established truth is true.” I’m not sure what the late Baron Hailsham of St. Marylebone would have made of a new account of that same revolution by Yale professor Steve Pincus. Meticulously researched and deftly written, Pincus’s book demolishes established truths (actually untruths) about the Glorious Revolution only to cram 1688 into a corset (“the first [...]
Intellectual Feast
November 2, 2009
1688: The First Modern Revolution by Steve Pincus; published originally in National Review
It is easier to describe the appearance of Gerald Tyrwhitt (1883-1950), the 14th, and strangest, Lord Berners, than the man himself. In his short story The Love-Bird, Osbert Sitwell gave his hero (a version of Berners) a “natural air of quiet, ugly distinction.” Cecil Beaton thought that Berners resembled “a bald wax figure in a cheap clothes shop,” while the cat-loving author Beverley Nichols was suitably feline, claiming that there was “a legend that nobody who has ever seen Gerald in his bath [was] ever quite the same again.”The mismatch between this once-renowned aesthete’s disappointing looks and his lifelong [...]
Lord Ha-Ha
August 10, 2009
Lord Berners - Composer Writer Painter by Peter Dickinson; published originally in The Weekly Standard
To find even a quick allusion to the White Russian civil-war commander Baron Roman Nikolai Maximilian von Ungern-Sternberg (1886–1921) is to be pulled into a past too strange to be believable and too terrible not to be. Three years ago, I was working on an article on Mongolia for National Review. When the text I’d submitted for editing was returned, a reference to the country’s “brief, brutal, and bizarre rule [by] a crazed Baltic baron” was questioned: “Are you certain about this?” As James Palmer’s absorbing, wonderfully written new biography of this gargoyle khan, exterminationist anti-Semite, paranoid mystic, and (some [...]
Heart of Darkness
July 6, 2009
The Bloody White Baron: The Extraordinary Story of the Russian Nobleman Who Became the Last Khan of Mongolia, by James Palmer; published originally in National Review
There are, I suppose, various possible things I might do after failing to reconcile with an estranged wife because of my refusal to give up alcohol. Becoming a drink columnist for a national newspaper is not one of them. Then I’m not Kingsley Amis. Then again, Elizabeth Jane Howard soon ceased to be Mrs. Kingsley Amis. Oh well. Some or all of those columns later re-appeared, clean-shaven, refreshed, and tidied-up as Every Day Drinking (“Being paid twice for the same basic work is always agreeable”), the second of three books (the other two are On Drink and How’s Your Glass?) [...]
Notes of a drink-man
January 1, 2009
Everyday Drinking: The Distilled Kingsley Amis (Kingsley Amis, introduction by Christopher Hitchens).; published originally in The New Criterion
If you are searching for a few scraps of comfort about the nature of our species, you would do very well to avoid Blood & Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism, the latest in a series of profoundly depressing books by the British historian Michael Burleigh. If, on the other hand, your objective is to examine the current global eruption of Islamic extremism through a wider perspective than the usual minaret, mullah, and middle-eastern rancor, Blood & Rage is an essential, imperative read, and well worth crossing the cyber pond to buy (it’s as yet unavailable in the United States). [...]
Sacred monsters
October 1, 2008
Blood & Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism by Michael Burleigh.; published originally in The New Criterion
Sometimes the smallest of things can illuminate the largest. A fossil tells the story of massive planetary change, a line or two of poetry does more to explain trench warfare than a dozen history books, and the miniatures of Nicholas Hilliard bring Gloriana’s long vanished England back to iridescent, dangerous life. In writing “Lenin’s Brain” (Hoover Institution Press, 163 pages, $15), Houston University professor Paul R. Gregory has mined the Hoover Institution’s extraordinary collection of Soviet archival material to come up with 14 brief, deftly chosen tales that brilliantly illuminate the cruelties, the absurdities, and the failures of the USSR’s [...]
A Cabinet of Soviet Curiosities
May 21, 2008
Lenin's Brain by Paul R. Gregory; published originally in The New York Sun
It’s not just the fact that Edward Lucas is a quietly proud, quietly amused holder of Lithuania’s Order of Gediminas (Fifth Class) that distinguishes him from many other non-native (he’s English) commentators on Eastern Europe; it’s also the depth of his interest in, and sympathy for, this long-contested stretch of territory’s cultures and peoples, an interest and a sympathy that resonate throughout this fine, timely, and thought-provoking new book. It’s an interest he has pursued at first hand. Lucas (whom — full disclosure — I’ve known for more than 20 years) spent time in Poland as a student, and has [...]
Round Two?
May 5, 2008
The New Cold War: Putin’s Russia and the Threat to the West, by Edward Lucas.; published originally in National Review
It is fair to assume that any volume with space for a discussion of the “crisis” in mid-20th-century Soviet children’s theater is aimed at a specialist audience. That said, if the subject of “Children’s World” (Yale University Press, 736 pages, $45), Oxford professor Catriona Kelly’s immense, imaginative, and thoroughly researched new book — a history of child-rearing in Russia between the twilight of the tsars and the fall of Gorbachev — is somewhat academic, her prose style is not. She writes clearly, keeps her use of pedagogic jargon to a minimum, and even leaves room for occasional flashes of dry, [...]
Children of the Revolution
March 5, 2008
Children's World by Catriona Kelly; published originally in The New York Sun
Judging by the tone and the content, if not the length, of his epic, sprawling, and (on several levels) fascinating new biography of Richard Nixon, Conrad Black is not inclined to attempt much analysis of what, ultimately, made Tricky Dick tick.. There have, he snorts, “been many amateur psychoanalyses of Nixon, [but] none of any apparent validity or value.” None?When Black refers to the “psycho-media speculation” contained within press coverage of the various medical disasters that befell the former president in the immediate aftermath of his resignation, he doesn’t mean it as a term of approbation. Now it is true [...]
Fixin’ Nixon
March 1, 2008
Richard M. Nixon: A Life in Full, by Conrad Black.; published originally in The New Criterion
It has been the worse part of a century since the bloody birth and savage adolescence of the Soviet state, but the events of those years are still obscure — lost in time, muddled by propaganda, and treated, even now, as the stuff of spin. Those terrible decades remain camouflaged, murky and mysterious, glimpsed mainly in shadow or in tantalizing, elusive outline. They have been best illuminated not in nonfiction accounts, but in novels, short stories, and verse — by Solzhenitsyn’s zek grateful for his day “without a dark cloud,” by the deadpan of Shalamov’s spare, unsparing Kolyma Tales, by Ahkmatova’s torn, desperate, [...]
The Lives of Others
February 11, 2008
The Whisperers: Private Life in Stalin’s Russia,by Orlando Figes.; published originally in National Review
Mark Ruttenberg, the hero of “An Ordinary Spy” (Bloomsbury, 288 pages, $23.95), Joseph Weisberg’s deft, sour, and clever new novel of espionage, bureaucracy, and disenchantment, is — it is true — a spy. But he’s no James Bond. Just read what happens, or doesn’t, when he shows up for a celebration at the Russian embassy in the country to which, as a novice CIA agent, he has recently been posted. The poor fellow fails to make any real progress with the general who is the most important target in the room, he gets “tipsy” on two shots of vodka, and [...]
Spies Like Us
January 16, 2008
An Ordinary Spy by Joseph Weisberg.; published originally in The New York Sun
One of the more poignant features of the current competition among Republican presidential hopefuls, fiercely fighting for a chance to lose to Senator Clinton in 2008, has been a series of missions to Maggie. Mitt Romney saw Margaret Thatcher, the former British prime minister, late last year in Washington, D.C., while Fred Thompson and Rudy Giuliani were at pains to include meetings with the Iron Lady in the course of their recent trips to London. The political consequences of such encounters will, I’d guess, be minimal, but the briskly written, perceptive, and, ultimately, moving “Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher: A [...]
We Happy Two
November 5, 2007
Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher: A Political Marriage by Nicholas Wapshott; published originally in The New York Sun
When Josef Stalin finally succumbed to the stroke he so richly deserved, a distraught Pablo Neruda mourned the death of this “giant. … the noon, the maturity of man and the peoples.” Such attitudes are, mercifully, now rare. Once known genially as “Uncle Joe,” Stalin is now regularly reviled as a monster and a despot to be ranked with history’s worst. Despite this, it continues to be the case that, in the popular imagination, the name Stalin fails to deliver anything like the sense of horror conjured up by Hitler. The reasons include the persistence of leftist ideology, the fact [...]
The Godfather, Part I: Stalin as a Boy
October 24, 2007
Young Stalin by Simon Sebag Montefiore; published originally in
It was Henry “Chips” Channon, one of the most entertaining, and informative, of Britain’s twentieth-century political diarists, who asked what was more “dull than a discreet diary.” Quite. Yet in some ways it is the discretion of the diaries just published by Alastair Campbell, Tony Blair’s former press secretary (and much, much more), which makes them so interesting. ]What’s in them, I suspect, matters far less than what’s been left out. The published diaries amount to “only” 350,000 words out of the more than two million Campbell wrote between starting work for the then-opposition leader Blair in 1994 and resigning [...]
Campbell’s Soup
October 1, 2007
The Blair Years: Extracts from the Alistair Campbell Diaries, by Alistair Campbell.; published originally in The New Criterion
In the course of humanity’s long, violent history, there was one brief, happy interlude, a decade or so on either side of 1900, when those fortunate enough to live in the more advanced parts of the planet were able to persuade themselves that barbarism had been banished from their culture, never to return. To those luckiest of men, the last true optimists, the barriers — psychological, political, and technological — that separated them from the savagery of the past were as reassuringly robust as the stout, solid bourgeois architecture then transforming their cities. This self-satisfaction we now know was pure [...]
Hearts of Darkness
September 19, 2007
Lenin, Stalin, and Hitler by Robert Gellately; published originally in The New York Sun
Despite unprecedented social, political, economic, and cultural upheaval, there is, still, just a part of this country’s vision of itself that is forever Bedford Falls. That was an idea of nation as extended community, diverse, but not too diverse, a land of opportunity, certainly, but one where no one was left too far behind, or ended up too far ahead. There was Potter, but he was an outsider, the moneyed exception that proved the modest rule, the rule that was also an ideal, of an America where everyone was in the same boat. Robert Frank, the author of the entertaining, [...]
In the Land Of Mammon
August 15, 2007
Richistan: A Journey Through the American Wealth Boom and the Lives of the New Rich; published originally in The New York Sun
Clio, that most elusive of Muses, can be glimpsed, but never caught. The interpretation of history is forever in flux, as much reflection of the present as window on the past. There are few better examples of this than England’s turbulent 17th century. Depending on whom you asked, and when, its conflicts were painful, but ultimately progressive; painful, but ultimately reactionary; or painful, but ultimately pointless. The natural response to the publication of yet another interpretation of one of the pivotal events of that century, the “Glorious Revolution” of 1688, is to ask, what now? According to Michael Barone, the [...]
1688 and All That
July 30, 2007
"Our First Revolution:The Remarkable British Upheaval That Inspired America’s Founding Fathers", by Michael Barone; published originally in National Review
If there’s one voice that can be heard above the hubbub described in Emily Cockayne‘s aptly titled new book, it is the voice, splenetic, dyspeptic, and thoroughly fed up, of the grumbler in high dudgeon. For all their traditional stoicism, the English have always known how to complain, and to do so with an acerbity and wit that leaves more famously querulous nations (yes, Jacques, yes, Pierre, I’m talking about you) looking like little more than whiny schoolchildren. When it comes to the topic of “Hubbub” (Yale University Press, 335 pages, $35), the squalor, grubbiness, and general unpleasantness of everyday [...]
Stench & the City
July 11, 2007
"Hubbub" by Emily Cockayne; published originally in The New York Sun
To cross over into East Berlin in the 1970s, as I did on a couple of occasions, was to take a trip that, even then, seemed like a voyage back into a lost, almost unimaginable era. The rampaging ideologies, cruel and convinced, that had done so much to wreck Europe were in retreat across the western part of the continent, their fervor dimmed by exhaustion, bitter experience, sweet, if uneven, prosperity, and, credit where credit’s due, careful American supervision. In East Berlin, by contrast, it was still 1945 or, if you prefer that date of a future that already appeared [...]
Something There Is That Doesn’t Love a Wall
May 30, 2007
The Berlin Wall: A World Divided, 1961–89 by Frederick Taylor.; published originally in The New York Sun
Of all the legends with which humanity deludes itself there are few more persistent, enchanting, and tormenting than that of a lost golden age. The Jews of the Old Testament pined for Eden, and the ancient Greeks dreamed of Arcadia. In the fantasies of many modern Britons, that vanished, magical idyll may have taken place on the island they call home, and not that many years ago, but that has only sharpened the sense of loss and tightened its grip on the English imagination. This particular golden age was said to have been ushered in with a funeral, that of [...]
England’s Arcadia
May 2, 2007
The Perfect Summer, by Juliet Nicolson; published originally in The New York Sun
If you have not heard of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, you haven’t been paying attention, you haven’t been reading your National Review, and you are probably unaware just how near Europe may be to serious sectarian disorder. You’ve also missed out on the remarkable story of how an obscure refugee from Somalia rose to become a leading figure in the fight against the oppression of Muslim women, and a prominent member of the Dutch parliament, only to be forced by fear for her safety to cross the Atlantic into what looks a lot like exile in America. Now, thanks to the [...]
Pilgrim’s Progress
April 30, 2007
Infidel, by Ayaan Hirsi Ali; published originally in National Review
If there is one thing, and one thing only, to be grasped about Britain’s failure to head off Hitler in time, it’s that it was almost certainly inevitable. Unfortunately, this is something that readers of “Troublesome Young Men” ( Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 448 pages, $27.50), a new book that explains how Winston Churchill rose to power and appeasement fell, will have to discover from another, more balanced source. What’s more, to describe “Troublesome Young Men” as a “new” book in anything other than the most literal sense is to be too kind. Yes, the additional, if occasionally rather gossipy, [...]
Victory at All Costs
April 11, 2007
Troublesome Young Men by Lynne Olsen; published originally in The New York Sun
The dust of those doomed towers had barely begun to settle before some Americans began asking themselves who, beyond Al Qaeda, was really responsible. Suspects included the Jews (as usual), the sinister Bush White House, the complacent Clinton White House and, in the view of Jerry Falwell, God. It’s a tribute to the power of his imagination that, despite this strong competition, in “The Enemy At Home” (Doubleday, 333 pages, $26.95), Dinesh D’Souza has managed to come up with a startlingly original selection of fresh suspects ranging from Madonna to Robert Mapplethorpe‘s awkwardly positioned whip. In essence, argues Mr. D’Souza, [...]
The Wicked West
February 2, 2007
The Enemy at Home by Dinesh D'Souza; published originally in The New York Sun
If, in 1932, nearly 15 years after the catastrophe of the “war to end all wars” had finally drawn to a close, any Britons were still foolish, complacent, or naïve enough to cling to their island nation’s traditional sense of inviolability, Stanley Baldwin, the country’s once-and-future prime minister, wanted to smash that illusion beyond repair. Speaking to the House of Commons in November of that year, he warned that the “man in the street [had] to realize that there is no power on earth that can protect him from being bombed. Whatever people may tell him, the bomber will always [...]
Battered Kingdom
January 3, 2007
Blitz: The Story of December, 29th, 1940 by Margaret Gaskin; published originally in The New York Sun
I was waiting to hear what the English poet Christopher Logue had done to the Iliad, and I was worried. The omens, threatening an evening of eat-your-greens earnestness, would have troubled the most phlegmatic of soothsayers. As for the theater in which I found myself, it was more depressing than Ford’s after Booth. A long way off Broadway in all but the most geographical sense, it was a hard-seat hall a few minutes’ walk from those now-vanished towers. The only thing emptier than the bleak, Beckett-bare stage was an auditorium begging for tumbleweed. We had been told that the entire [...]
Logue’s Odyssey
December 1, 2006
Christopher Logue's the Iliad; published originally in The New Criterion
Right at the beginning of this mad, maddening, provocative, and sometimes beautifully written book, “Nicole Kidman” (Alfred A. Knopf, 304 pages, $24.95), David Thomson admits that he “loves” Nicole Kidman, a confession that is both essential and superfluous. Skeptical as we all should be about long-distance psychoanalysis, Mr. Thomson’s book is more love letter than biography, both a meditation on obsession and a monument to it. He writes: There she is in profile, her right shoulder raised, her chin lowered … with just a flap of brown cloth covering her breasts and a considerable expanse of white skin … a [...]
Look but Don’t Touch
September 6, 2006
"Nicole Kidman" by David Thomson; published originally in The New York Sun
There’s a bright, shining, merciful moment, right towards the end of this infuriating, odd, but occasionally perceptive polemic, when its author, Claire Berlinski, says what needs saying about the rancid and rabid anti-Americanism now disgracing Europe’s public discourse: “[It] is a cultist system of faith, rather than a set of rational beliefs, and as such is impervious to revision upon confrontation with facts, logic, evidence, gestures of good will, public relations campaigns, or attempts on the part of the American secretary of state to be a better, more sensitive listener.” Accurate enough, but her observation that there is nothing Americans [...]
Euro Scare?
May 8, 2006
Menace in Europe:Why the Continent’s Crisis Is America’s, Too, by Claire Berlinski; published originally in National Review
If you have ever needed reminding of a nation’s capacity for ingratitude, the story of Alan Turing ought to do the trick. And if you have never heard of Alan Turing, that only proves the point. Born in 1912 into the cheese-paring and snobbery of Britain’s colonial administrative class, Turing emerged from a traditionalist family and an old-school education with a wild, unorthodox mind, and a record of achievement that establishes him as one of the most important mathematicians of the last century. In not much more than one astonishing decade, this extraordinary individual would not only play a critical [...]
Quiet Hero
January 30, 2006
The Man Who Knew Too Much: Alan Turing and the Invention of the Computer, by David Leavitt; published originally in National Review
If you need any confirmation that the glum little town that passes for this nation’s capital is hopelessly obsessed with itself, take a look at “Dog Days” (Riverhead Books, 288 pages, $23.95), the Washington frolic and first novel by Ana Marie Cox, the below-the-Beltway blogger better known as Wonkette. To get the most out of this book, you need to know beforehand what Ms. Cox has been up to on her blog. Sleazy, sarcastic, funny, and salacious (“Politics for People With Dirty Minds”), Wonkette first began lurking around computer terminals back in January 2004, a remote era lost in blogging [...]
Wonkette Jumps the Snark
January 6, 2006
Ana Marie Cox's "Dog Days"; published originally in The New York Sun
To British author Chris Cleave, it must have seemed like a dream come true. The rights to Incendiary, his first book, had been snapped up, an unusually large print-run had been prepared, and an extensive promotional campaign was in the works. In a sign of a best-seller to come, glossy posters advertising Incendiary were already up on the walls of London’s subway system designed to entice commuters into buying what many thought would be the summer’s big read. And then, on the very day that Cleave’s book was released, everything went horribly, tragically wrong. His dream, in a sense, became [...]
Incendiary Device
September 15, 2005
Incendiary, by Chris Cleave; published originally in National Review Online
Tt’s enough to make you choke on your fava beans. In bookstore new-fiction aisles, this was meant to be the summer of Hannibal Lecter: aesthete, Renaissance scholar, and serial killer. Instead he has had to share the limelight with Harry Potter, the schoolboy hero of a series of British children’s books. The second of these, The Chamber of Secrets, was released in the U.S. at about the same time as Thomas Harris’s Hannibal. On September 19, more than three months later, it was Number Three on the New York Times bestseller list, five places ahead of the unfortunate Dr. Lecter. [...]
It’s Witchcraft
July 15, 2005
Harry Potter: The Camber of Secrets, by J.K. Rowling; published originally in National Review Online
With Clint Eastwood reduced to making films about ladies who box, Bond, James Bond, is the last true man’s man. He blows smoke in the face of surgeons-general, adds no fruit juice to his martinis, and gives the pieties of feminism a pass. He has survived knives, a wife, bullets, nasty mechanical pincers, beatings, grenades, piranhas, and tortures too beastly to describe in a family newspaper. He’s seen off Blofeld, Goldfinger, Scaramanga, No, Drax, and even that impertinent oaf, Austin Powers. He has weathered the challenges of SMERSH, Rosa Klebb’s shoes, Roger Moore’s safari suits, and the notion that M [...]
Potter’s Field
May 20, 2005
Charlie Higson's "SilverFin"; published originally in The New York Sun
There are few more ominous signs of a grim read ahead than “advance praise” by the pompous, pedestrian, and stupendously dull Bill Bradley. According to the former New Jersey lawmaker, “Death by a Thousand Cuts” (Princeton University Press, 372 pages, $29.95) is “immensely readable … an illuminating look at the estate tax and its implications for future American tax policy.” The phrases “tax policy” and “immensely readable” are not usually found in the same sentence, but Mr. Bradley is, for once, quite right. Written in a bright, breezy style, “Death by a Thousand Cuts” is as about as accessible as [...]
Roaring Back From – and for – the Dead
May 16, 2005
Death by a Thousand Cuts; published originally in The New York Sun
If you want to see what an apoplectic fit looks like in print, check out Michiko Kakutani’s review/denunciation in the New York Times of State of Fear, the latest book from Michael Crichton. Crichton is the author of Jurassic Park, Disclosure, The Andromeda Strain, and much more (or, in the case of Prey, less); in State of Fear he dares to challenge the numbskull pieties of “global warming” and that has made Michiko very mad indeed. State of Fear is, she writes, “shrill,” “preposterous,” and, horror of horrors, “right-wing.” So many angry, foam-flecked adjectives jostle for attention in the text [...]
Global Warning
February 28, 2005
State of Fear, by Michael Crichton; published originally in National Review
To call Ayn Rand, the high priestess of the human will, a mere force of nature would to her have been an insult as well as a cliche. But how else to describe this extraordinary, maddening, and indestructible individual? Born a century ago this year into the flourishing bourgeoisie of glittering, doomed St. Petersburg, Alisa Zinovyevna Rosenbaum was to triumph over revolution, civil war, Lenin’s dictatorship, an impoverished immigrant existence, and bad reviews in the New York Times to become a strangely important figure in the history of American ideas. Even the smaller details of Rand’s life come with the [...]
A Strangely Important Figure
January 26, 2005
Ayn Rand by Jeff Britting; published originally in The New York Sun
FOR those of us who like to believe, however tentatively, in human progress, the notion that there are 21st-century Americans who think that the brave, benign—and fictional—Harry Potter can be used as a recruitment officer for the occult is profoundly depressing. And yet there are surprisingly many who fear just that. For year after year now, different school districts across the country have faced complaints whenever the hero of Hogwarts rides his Nimbus 2000 broom- stick onto the curriculum or into the library. But the Lord, or the market, works in mysterious ways and those so harried by the thought [...]
The Trouble With Harry
December 31, 2004
"Shadowmancer" and "Wormwood" by G. P. Taylor.; published originally in National Review
It’s far too soon to know if the 2004 murder of Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh by a Muslim fanatic will turn out to be a warning heeded in time, or if it will prove to be just another episode in the decline of a country wrecked by the mixing of multiculturalism with mass immigration. Judging by the nature of the debate ahead of Holland’s upcoming elections, judging by the departure of parliamentarian Ayaan Hirsi Ali to the safer, more welcoming haven of America, and judging by this perceptive, misguided, depressing, and (sometimes unconsciously) revealing book, it will be the [...]
Cultural Suicide
December 4, 2004
Murder in Amsterdam: The Death of Theo van Gogh and the Limits of Tolerance, by Ian Buruma; published originally in National Review
Ian Kershaw is best known for “Hitler,” his two-volume, definitive account of one of history’s monsters. His new book, by contrast, deals with an irritating British nobleman who was at best a footnote, at worst a nonentity. In telling the strange, sad story of the lord who tried to befriend a fuhrer, Mr. Kershaw highlights the English ineptitude that was to prove so helpful to the German dictator throughout the 1930s. “Making Friends With Hitler” (The Penguin Press, 488 pages, $29.95) also comes with a disturbing contemporary resonance. In part it’s a tale of people living in the comfort of [...]
Stumbling Down the Road to Hell
December 2, 2004
Making Friends With Hitler; published originally in The New York Sun
Charles Murray have a difficult time in high school? Judging by what he writes, when he writes, and how he writes, he’s someone who would not have enjoyed the conformist, unimaginative world of contemporary American secondary education. A controversialist who never knows when to stop, a math geek who understands what counts, Murray was probably jostled in the school yard, pushed about in the cafeteria, and, in that hallmark of intellectual independence, repeatedly hauled up in front of the principal. “Murray, don’t ever, ever argue with your teachers again.” His best-known work, 1994’s The Bell Curve (co-written with Richard J. [...]
Measuring Man
December 1, 2004
Human Accomplishment by Charles Murray; published originally in Hudson Institute
All it takes for evil to prevail, warned Burke, is “for enough good men to do nothing.” True; but that doesn’t mean that the good men cannot occasionally relax with a good laugh or two. It might even help them, especially in a situation of the kind the West faces today: a war with an ideology so dedicated to the destruction of happiness that, in the shape of the Taliban, it made laughing too loud in public a crime. (For women, anyway.) In Florence of Arabia, his dark, disturbing, and very funny new satire, Christopher Buckley highlights the cruelty of [...]
Queen of The Desert
November 8, 2004
"Florence of Arabia," by Christopher Buckley; published originally in National Review
If there’s anything more guaranteed to set off my inner sans-culotte than pampered, arrogant Teresa Heinz Kerry, it’s a gathering of international bureaucrats, the spoiled, sanctimonious, worthless, and annoying aristocrats of our own sadly yet to be ancient regime. Locusts in limousines, they periodically descend on some unfortunate city, clogging the streets with their retinues, the restaurants with their greed, and the newspapers with their self-importance. Seen from this perspective, and judging by its remarkably unflattering cover photograph, “The World’s Banker” (The Penguin Press, 462 pages, $29.95) an account by the Washington Post’s Sebastian Mallaby of James Wolfensohn and the [...]
Other People’s Money
September 30, 2004
The World's Banker; published originally in The New York Sun
Food Fight: The Inside Story of the Food Industry, America’s Obesity Crisis, and What We Can Do about It by Kelly Brownell and Katherine Battle Horgen It is difficult to single out what is most objectionable about this hectoring, lecturing, and altogether dejecting piece of work, but perhaps it’s the moment when its authors credit the rest of us with the IQs of greedy rodents Quoting s study that shows that, presented with a cornucopia of carbohydrates and wicked fatty treats, laboratory rats will abandon a balanced, healthy diet in favor of dangerous excess, they draw a rather insulting conclusion: [...]
The Fat Police
January 26, 2004
"Food Fight," by Kelly D. Brownell and Katherine Battle Horgen.; published originally in National Review
Abraham Lincoln, a wise man and a brave one too (he was speaking to the sober souls gathered at a meeting of a Springfield temperance society), once said that the damage alcohol can do comes not “from the use of a bad thing, but from the abuse of a very good thing.” Drunkenness, not drink, was the real demon. Sensible words; yet, in their dealings with the bottle, his countrymen still lurch between wretched excess and excessive wretchedness. Moderation remains elusive. After the binging, there’s always the hangover: dreary years of finger-wagging, sermonizing, and really, really dumb laws. Just ask [...]
Killjoy Was Here
December 31, 2003
"The Spirits of America: A Social History of Alcohol," by Eric Burns.; published originally in National Review
All Day Permanent Red by Christopher Logue CHRISTOPHER LOGUE has been a dealer in stolen property (briefly), a prisoner in a Crusader castle (16 months), a pornographer (the book Lust), and, probably no less discreditably, an actor, a poet, and a writer of screenplays. As if this weren’t enough, for over four decades this versatile Englishman has been engaged in a “reworking” of the Iliad. It is not, he is at pains to stress, a translation (he knows no Greek), but an episodic “account” of the ancient epic that has already taken far longer to produce than Troy took to [...]
The Bloodstained Rise
November 10, 2003
"All Day Permanent Red: The First Battle Scenes of Homer's Iliad Rewritten," by Christopher Logue.; published originally in National Review
Profoundly Disturbing: Shocking Movies that Changed History by Joe Bob Briggs The title is reassuringly lurid and the cover comfortingly nasty, but, on opening this book, anxious readers may worry that Joe Bob has left the drive-in. Now that would be profoundly disturbing. Author, journalist, cable-TV stalwart, and former NR columnist, Briggs overcame fictitious origins and nonexistent competition to become America’s finest drive-in-movie critic. He saw Nail Gun Massacre and he watched All Cheerleaders Die. Who else could take on that sort of responsibility? He is the Zagat of the Z-movie, the one indispensable guide for those who like slaughter, sex, [...]
Horror Show
August 26, 2003
Profoundly Disturbing: Shocking Movies That Changed History!; published originally in National Review
Saying Yes: In Defense of Drug use, by Jacob Sullum JACOB SULLUM is a brave man. In his first book, the entertaining and provocative For Your Own Good, he attacked the excesses of anti-smoking activism and was duly—and unfairly—vilified as a Marlboro mercenary, a hard-hearted shill for Big Tobacco with little care for nico- tine’s wheezing victims. Fortunately, he was undeterred. In Saying Yes, Sullum, formerly of NATIONAL RF.VIEW and now a senior editor at Reason magazine, turns his attention to the most contentious of all the substance wars, the debate over illegal drugs. Sullum being Sullum.. he manages to [...]
Everybody Must Get Stoned?
June 20, 2003
"Saying Yes: In Defense of Drug Use," by Jacob Sullum.; published originally in National Review
Peacekeeping Fiascoes of the 1990s: Causes, Solutions, and U.S. Interests, by Frederick Fleitz. With his good intentions and his blue helmet, the U.N. peacekeeper was an icon of post-World War II internationalism. He was G.I. Joe for the Eleanor Roosevelt set, muscular assurance that the days of the feeble League of Nations would never return. And for a while it seemed to work. The record was far from perfect, but from Cyprus to West New Guinea to Namibia, the presence of relatively small numbers of U.N. troops was sufficient to separate warring forces and supervise the return to peace. The [...]
Keepers Without Peace
December 23, 2002
"Peacekeeping Fiascoes of the 1990s: Causes, Solutions, and U.S. Interests," by Frederick Fleitz.; published originally in National Review
Snobbery: The American Version, by Joseph Epstein The Englishman said to me, “oh you are writing for an American magazine.” The eyebrow arched, the lip curled, the cliché was confirmed over a smugly sipped cup of tea. English snobbery, again. To the rest of the world, it is our defining vice (full disclosure: I’m also from the scepter’d isle), something as English as military defeat is French. Fair enough: mine is a country obsessed by class. Only in England could a humorous essay (published in the 1950s by one of the Mitfords, naturally) on the distinctions between the language (“U”) [...]
Basic Instinct
September 1, 2002
Snobbery: The American Version by Joseph Epstein; published originally in Hudson Institute
Sakharov: A Biography, by Richard Lourie It takes more than a Bolshevik to erase history. Lenin intended his revolution to be a clean break with the unruly, uncontrollable past, but, in the end, he failed. Remnants of the older—and, for all its faults, more humane—Russia succeeded in enduring through three- quarters of a century of Communist brutality. Andrei Sakharov, the subject of this new biography by Richard Lourie, may have been born in the formative years of the Soviet dystopia, but he is best seen as a child of the earlier, finer civilization that the revolution had been designed to [...]
The Good Russian
August 12, 2002
"Sakharov: A Biography," by Richard Lourie; published originally in National Review
Back in the time of the revolution he was described as a gray blur, and it is as a gray blur that Stalin survives today, a nullity, a gap in our memory, an absence. In the lands of his old empire, they remember more, far, far more. The absence there is absent fathers, absent mothers, absent grandparents, absent uncles, absent aunts, absences in the millions, all victims of the monster who remains, remarkably, still present in Red Square (there’s a small bust at his burial site by the Kremlin’s walls and usually someone takes the trouble to leave a flower [...]
Hollow Laughter
July 16, 2002
Koba the Dread: Laughter and the Twenty Million by Martin Amis; published originally in National Review Online
The His Dark Materials trilogy, by Philip Pullman IT was, some said, the moment that literature for the young finally came of age. On January 22, Philip Pullman, a children’s writer (although he objects to that label), was awarded Britain’s prestigious Whitbread prize for the final installment of his best-selling His Dark Materials trilogy. In the opinion of the judges, The Amber Spyglass was Britain’s book of the year. It was an unprecedented honor for a work aimed at younger readers, but Pullman is a man who must be getting used to praise, and not just in Britain. His writing [...]
Sunday School for Atheists
March 25, 2002
"The Golden Compass," 'The Subtle Knife," and "The Amber Spyglass" by Philip Pullman; published originally in National Review
There is, let’s admit it, something grimly satisfying about having a prejudice confirmed. So, if you are one of those people who believe that there is absolutely nothing more to say about Charles and Di, Christopher Andersen’s new work, Diana’s Boys, is the book for you. Once again weary readers are presented with the same shop-soiled menagerie (mean queen, pained prince, plain Camilla, horrible Hewitt, foolish Fergie, loveable Tiggy, playboy Dodi), the same exhausted anecdotes (hysteria at Highgrove, bulimia in the palace, Charles’ confession of adultery, Diana’s TV interview, the rudeness at Harry’s birth), and, above all, that same doomed, [...]
Diana, Again
October 6, 2001
Diana's Boys: William and Harry and the Mother They Loved by Christopher Andersen.; published originally in National Review Online
WAS there a David Horowitz in Bosnia, a Cassandra warning of the cataclysm to come? For most ethnic conflicts are fairly predictable, and it’s not too difficult to identify who is going to start them. The underlying message of this collection of essays is that race relations in this country too are being deliberately poisoned, with potentially disastrous results. The culprits are a grubby group of demagogues and ideological hucksters, given their opportunity by the development of identity politics. It is worth reading what Horowitz has to say. After all, he was once a prominent ’60s radical, a “progressive” pur [...]
Hating Whitey and Other Progressive Causes.
May 22, 2000
"Hating Whitney and Other Progressive Causes," by David Horowitz.; published originally in National Review
IT’S enough to make you choke on your fava beans. In bookstore new-fiction aisles, this was meant to be the summer of Hannibal Lector: aesthete. Renaissance scholar, and serial killer. Instead be has had to share the limelight with Harry Potter, the schoolboy hero of a series of British children’s books. The second of these. The Chamber of Secrets, was released in the U.S. at about the same time as Thomas Harris’s Hannibal. On September 19, more than three months later, it was Number Three on the New York Times bestseller list, five places ahead of the unfortunate Dr. Lecter. [...]
It’s Witchcraft
October 11, 1999
J.K. Rowling"s "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone," "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets" and "Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban."; published originally in National Review
SPACE aliens are a nasty, bug-eyed lot, always plotting to subjugate the galaxy and firing off death rays. Not much use to us humans, you might think. But you would be wrong. As a plot device, the extraterrestrial can he most useful, a light shone on the peculiarities of this planet. And so, in his latest, and very funny, novel, Christopher Buckley employs a motley and distinctly home-grown bunch of ETs to take a look at a close encounter between two different worlds, both of which happen to be located here on Earth. His hero, John Banion, is a king [...]
Contact
April 19, 1999
"Little Green Men," by Christopher Buckley; published originally in National Review
SUMMER reading is supposed to be light. But those who prefer a bit of darkness, to give them some shade from the heat of the sun, may wish to consider this fascinating book by Mark Fuhrman, whose theme may put them in mind of Shakespeare. Yes, Shakespeare, Yes, that Mark Fuhrman. “Murder,” wrote the Bard, “moves like a ghost.” For a ghost always leaves trails of ectoplasm bebind it, and so in its way does murder. Its victims haunt us, and it has long been believed that their restless spirits wander the earth calling for revenge. And that is the [...]
Ghost Story
September 14, 1998
"Murder in Greenwich: Who Killed Martha Moxley?" by Mark Fuhrman.; published originally in National Review
Poor, sad Princess Diana. Within hours of the tragedy in Paris, her death was being honored in the way most characteristic of our time: a conspiracy theory relayed over the Internet. She was murdered, you see, by British intelligence. The mother of a future King of England could not be allowed to marry an Egyptian. Ridiculous, of course, although Muammar Qaddafi seemed to think that there was something to it. Which would not surprise Daniel Pipes. His fascinating, though all too brief, new book traces the development of conspiracy theories from the time of the Crusades to the Roswell era. [...]
The Plot Sickens
December 31, 1997
Conspiracy: How the Paranoid Style Flourishes and Where It Comes From by Daniel Pipes; published originally in National Review
So now we know. The controversy is over. UFOs are real, and never mind the latest Air Force denial, hopefully entitled The Roswell Report: Case Closed. Armed with the credibility that comes from a previous book that was “a major source for Oliver Stone’s film JFK.” Jim Marrs’s “monumental undertaking” is, in the opinion of his publishers, “no less than the last word on the subject.” Even for those members of the “smug . . . intelligentsia” who persist in their disbelief, this could make for an interesting read. For, as Mr. Marrs makes clear, UFOs are now part of [...]
Lost in Space
July 28, 1997
Alien Agenda: Investigating the Extraterrestrial Presence among Us; published originally in National Review
“It will not,” writes James Gardner, “be obvious to everyone why O. J. Simpson’s name should appear at the head of a chapter that touches upon Darwinism, the Holocaust, and French post-structuralist philosopy.” Quite. But, as The Age of Extremism makes clear, we live in an age of doubt. If nothing can be proved absolutely, then nothing can be absolutely true. But this is a flawed skepticism, one that paves the way for extremism. For, as Mr. Gardner explains, its corollary is a willingness to believe anything—” as long as it is at variance with received opinion or unadorned common [...]
Off Center
June 30, 1997
The Age of Extremism: The Enemies of Compromise in American Politics, Culture, and Race Relations by James Gardner; published originally in National Review
Witch doctors! It’s an engaging title, promising bile, sarcasm, and maybe, just perhaps, a sneer or two. After all, this is a book about management gurus, those experts whose ever-changing theories fill bookstores and empty factories. Well paid and annoying, they scream out for a little abuse. In this book, they don’t get it. As the authors note, somewhat smugly (they do write for The Economist), “it would have been much easier (and often far more pleasurable) to have trashed the industry.” But they reject the hatchet in favor of a “scalpel job.” In many respects they succeed. Often drily [...]
Gaga Gurus
April 7, 1997
The Witch Doctors: Making Sense of the Management Gurus, hy John Micklethwait and Adrian Wooldridge; published originally in National Review
Back in the 1950s space aliens were a straightforward bunch. By and large, they wanted little more than world conquest. Comfortingly, they were also imaginary. To be sure, there were those who claimed they have seen UFOs, but the aliens themselves remained elusive, “space brothers” of interest only to “contactees” such as “Professor” George Adamski, a California hamburger vendor with an extensive Venusian social circle. However, by 1992 the B-movie bogeyman had become real, moving from Hollywood to the even stranger surroundings of a five-day conference at MIT organized by David Pritchard, an MIT physicist, and John E. Mack, professor [...]
Grey Zone
September 11, 1995
Abduction: Human Encounters with Aliens, by John E. Mack, MD; published originally in National Review
As Anne Applebaum writes in the introduction to this evocative and entertaining book, “Warsaw gave me a taste for instability.” It is no surprise, therefore, that 1991 saw her heading toward the disintegrating Soviet Union. Rather than visit Moscow or Leningrad, however, she chose to journey down the empire’s western frontier, from the Baltic to the Black Sea. In earlier times much of this region was known to Poles as the “Kresy,” a word for “borderlands” that implies “a lack of demarcation, an endless horizon with nothing certain beyond.” A vast flat plain, these borderlands have attracted invaders from east [...]
On the Edge
January 23, 1995
Between East and West: Across the Borderlands of Europe, by Anne Applebaum; published originally in National Review
THIS entertaining, thought-provoking, and frequently amusing book will disturb those who believe that the American financial community has learned from past disasters. Rather, as the author writes, the best that can be said is that “sons and daughters tend to re-enact the errors of their grandparents more so than those of their parents.” To prove his point Mr. Grant takes the reader through recurring crises in such areas as real estate, lending, and farmland. While Mr. Grant explains that “‘More’ is the best brief description of the evolution of credit in the United States,” this is not his only theme. [...]
Money of the Mind: Borrowing and Lending in America from the Civil War to Michael Milken.
July 6, 1992
Money of the Mind: Borrowing and Lending in America from the Civil War to Michael Milken, by James Grant; published originally in National Review